The link to the article on Wingate v. Fulford is here
“Wingate was ultimately arrested for violating a Stafford County ordinance that made it a crime to refuse an officer’s request for ID “if the surrounding circumstances are such as to indicate to a reasonable man that the public safety requires such identification.” After the prosecutor dropped the charges, Wingate sued, arguing that his Fourth Amendment rights were violated by the unlawful detainment and arrest.”